top of page
  • Writer's pictureRobert Boyd-Roundel Legal Costs

Part 36 where accurate valuation may be an issue.

In high-value cases, it is often a tactic by opponents to make quite high-level offers of settlement early and this is common in high-value cases concerning a minor. When you are unsure as to the level of disability, which is particularly difficult when the client is a minor, the question, therefore, falls how you assess a Part 36 Offer in these circumstances?

From a practical point of view, advice from Counsel is obviously justified so a second opinion is sought and to assist in protecting protection from any ATE policy.

Another good tactic would be to ask the opponent for the evidence that they are using to value the claim. If the case involves a minor, it would be unusual for the Court to restrict the child’s damages unless full disclosure was given at the time, which would be a good point to raise with the opponent.

Relevant case law

In terms of case law, a relevant case to consider would be SG v Hewitt [2012] EWCA Civ 1053 which provides that where it is uncertain as to the prognosis in the case of a disability the normal consequences do not apply when the prognosis is uncertain. To that extent, it would be appropriate to raise this case with the opponent and request full disclosure to enable you to value the case. If of course, they cannot provide evidence, that would be a good argument later that normal costs consequences should not apply in accordance with CPR 36.17(5) and this Judgment.

Another helpful Judgment would be JMX (A Child) v Norfolk Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2017] EWHC 3082 (QB) which states that there are five express considerations in relation to CPR 36.17(5) or that whether there is an exception to normal Part 36 consequences:

a) The terms of the offer;

b) The stage in proceedings when the offer is made;

c) The information available to the parties at the time the offer was made;

d) The conduct of the parties with regard to the giving of or refusal to give information for the purposes of enabling the offer to be made or evaluated;

e) Whether the offer was a genuine attempt to settle the proceedings.

To that extent the aforementioned case is useful to quote in an attempt for full disclosure to be provided or alternatively as a marker in the file that you can later come back to should, you wish to later rely on CPR 36.17(5) for factors outside of your control.

Roundel Legal Costs are experts in Bill drafting and costs recovery.

To see how we can help you get paid for the work that you do get in touch today:

62 views21 comments

Recent Posts

See All


4 days ago

Embark on an exclusive shopping tour in Spain’s top fashion destinations. Visit designer boutiques in Madrid and Barcelona explore artisanal markets in Seville and enjoy private consultations with magicalspain fashion experts. Your tour will ensure you find unique and luxurious items to take home.


Jun 11

Energy staffing companies provide ongoing support to their candidates even after placement. This support includes missiondrivenrecruiter com career counseling professional development opportunities and performance feedback. Continuous support helps workers succeed in their roles and fosters long-term career growth.


Jun 10

The concept of "parenting plans" has gained popularity in child custody arrangements, emphasizing collaborative co-parenting. A parenting plan is a written agreement that outlines how parents will share responsibilities and time with their child. It typically includes schedules for visitation, holidays, and decision-making protocols. By clearly defining expectations and arrangements, parenting plans help thesagelawgroup ca reduce conflicts and provide a predictable, structured environment for the child.


Jun 05

Wallet recovery options are crucial in case of device loss or damage. Most wallets offer recovery processes using www thecryptomerchant com seed phrases or backups. Ensure you understand the recovery options provided by your chosen wallet. Properly set up and store your recovery methods to safeguard your funds.


Jun 05

The development of solar and battery microgrids is transforming energy distribution. Microgrids are localized energy systems that can operate independently from the central grid. By integrating sundial solar nh solar panels and battery storage microgrids enhance energy resilience reduce transmission losses and support renewable energy adoption. They are particularly beneficial for remote areas military bases and critical infrastructure. Microgrids represent a step towards more decentralized and resilient energy systems.

bottom of page